Yellow flags get a lot of attention, but they’re a small part of the job description for NFL officials. (AP)
Before we go under the hood to review an NFL official’s day planner, here are some basics:
How much do NFL officials work during the season?
A conservative estimate is 20-25 hours week – not including travel. For head referees 30-35 hours. But there’s always another game to watch or another page in the rule book worth re-reading.
How much do NFL refs earn?
Last season rookies made more than $75,000. The most senior refs just under $200,000.
Bill Carollo retired in 2009 after 20 years as an NFL official, most of them as a head referee. Today the 60-year-old Wisconsin resident manages the officials in four Division-I college football conferences. I asked Carollo to walk me through a referee’s week, starting at the end of a Sunday afternoon game.Sunday evening: The final whistle sounds
“We would actually go back to the hotel, have food brought in and look at the TV tape of it,” Carollo said. “We won’t get the coaches’ tape, which is the sideline and end zone shots they use to evaluate the players. We won’t get that until the next day. So there will be a brief review of all the penalties, any controversial plays.”
And like many jobs, there’s paperwork.
“As a referee I have to send in multiple reports to the league about the fouls, about anything that happened on the sideline or anything unusual in the game.”
NFL officials are flying home … or to wherever their other jobs take them. The vast majority of the 119 NFL officials have second careers. Many own businesses or hold senior management positions, but Carollo says tough economic times in recent years have led to bosses asking questions about the amount of time the NFL requires.
“Why don’t you work Fridays and Saturdays? Or why aren’t you working Mondays because you’ve got Monday Night Football?’ And now they’re playing Thursday night football,” Carollo said. “It becomes increasingly more difficult, so a lot of the guys are trying to do just officiating.”
On Mondays head refs also have a conference call with the front office. For most of his NFL career, Carollo was also an international account executive for IBM – a job that required regular travel to Europe, South America and Asia.
“So a lot of times I would work a ballgame, fly to Beijing. And then phone would ring, “I’m looking for you. There was a couple of offsides calls [we’d like to go over]. Where are you?’. I said, ‘I’m checking into my hotel in China.’”
NFL referees get instant feedback after every call – in the form of boos, cheers and screaming coaches.
They also get plenty of critiques from the league. The officiating in every game is graded by a former ref.
“We’ll get a pretty good report card, if you will. By Tuesday night all of the games in the NFL are graded and on Wednesday morning, they’ll send out a report to you,” Carollo said. “I get the report. I go over it with the person that graded it. Then I have a conference call with my crew and go over the game with them.”
With the previous game viewed, reviewed and reviewed again, it’s time to prep for Sunday’s match-up.
“By Tuesday, we’ll get video of the two teams, so I’ll sort through their typical formations, what types of plays they run. Is it 60 percent passing? Or is it 60 percent running? More of a football analysis,” Carollo said.
Each week, NFL officials also get a quiz – a written test on the rules of the game.
Friday night or Saturday morning, it’s time to fly out. Refs are required to arrive at least 24 hours before a game. They fly first-class and the league covers all their travel expenses. Once everyone’s in town, the crew meets for several hours, preparing for the next day’s game and reviewing the week’s quiz. Oh, and there’s more homework. A video:
“Every week, maybe 20 or 25 plays that happen throughout the league that could be a good learning experience. If we made a mistake last week, we want everyone to know the mistake. We don’t hide ‘em … internally. Just so if it happens again, we don’t make the same mistake.”
Sunday: “The Best Part of the Week”
There’s more pre-game prep on Sunday morning over breakfast, but before long it’s the moment coaches, players, fans and yes, refs have all been waiting for … game time.
“That’s the best part of the week. Sunday afternoon at kick-off, those three hours, it’s beautiful,” Carollo said. “There’s pressure and we’ll screw up calls and we’ll make some mistakes, but solving those problems and sorting through those difficult calls are why we do it,” Carollo said. “Just to see how good we really are, so that’s really what we work for … because it’s the hardest thing that most of us have ever tried to do.”
In June, the NFL announced that it would use replacement referees during negotiations with its officials. Key issues include the current pension system and whether referees should be considered full or part-time employees.
NFL Playoff Referees Should Have Our Sympathy, Not Scorn'
Bill Littlefield understands the difficulties of refereeing. As a ref for his daughter’s basketball game, he learned to appreciate just how hard it can be to wear the whistle.
Henry O. "Hammerin' Hank" Nichols (born 20 July, 1936) was an American college basketballreferee and later supervisor of officials. In 2012, he was inducted as a member of the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame. Nichols is also a member of the Philadelphia Big 5 Hall of Fame, Villanova Athletic Hall of Fame, the Philadelphia Athletic Hall of Fame, the Greater Buffalo Sports Hall of Fame, and the Pennsylvania Sports Hall of Fame. He officiated 10 National Collegiate Athletic Association(NCAA)Final Fours, a record 6 NCAA Men's Basketball National Championships, 3 NIT Finals, 2 Olympic Games and 1 European Championships. He was also the first official to work both the NIT and NCAA Championship Basketball Finals in a single year, and the first National Coordinator of Officials. Since 2004, he has worked as an Umpire Observer for Major League Baseball.
Nichols grew up in Niagara Falls, New York. In high school, he attended Bishop Duffy High and lettered in three sports. He earned a scholarship to Villanova University, where he played catcher. He also started on the freshman basketball team.
After graduation, Nichols spent two years in the Marine Corps, followed by three years playing minor league baseball in the Cincinnati Reds organization. In his last season (at age 27), he hit .330 as a player-manager in the Western Carolina League.
In the fall of 1969, while at Duke, Nichols started his officiating career with six freshman Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) basketball games. In 1970, Nichols became assistant professor in the Department of Education and Human Services at Villanova, where he would remain for the next 33 years. He also began officiating varsity games in the ECAC and the ACC.
In 1974, Nichols worked his first NCAA tournament, the first of 13 in a row. That season, Nichols was one of the officials for the 1974 North Carolina State-Maryland ACC championship game. Nichols said that game was the best he ever worked, and NC State's David Thompson as the greatest player he officiated. NC State won the game in overtime, and went on to win the national championship. At the time only one team from each conference made the NCAA Tournament.
"I just remember getting out of everybody's way," Nichols said. "Those players were so good. We just kind of watched them. It was a magnificent game."
In 1975, Nichols worked the first of 10 Final Fours, and the first of six national championships. The championship game was John Wooden’s final game as the head coach at UCLA.
In 1976, he officiated at the Olympic Games in Montreal, the first of two Olympic assignments. His second would come in 1984 in Los Angeles.
NCAA National Coordinator of Officials
In 1987, Nichols became the first NCAA coordinator of officials. He spent 22 years in that position. Nichols said, "the goal was to try to get guys across the country to officiate the same way, not have the ACC be different from the Big Ten and the Big Ten different from the Pac-10. We wanted to teach guys to ref better, to try to get them to be more consistent. We didn't want them to be another factor when teams played on the road. We wanted them to stand tall and figure out tough situations. I think a lot of that has been accomplished." While in this position, Nichols also was the secretary/editor of the Basketball Rules Committee from 1991-1997.
Nichols retired after the 2007-2008 season. He was replaced by John Adams.